Differences in Flour Explained - Sift Out Your Flour Issues

I have been having an email conversation with anothermilling process, many of the nutrients were lost and
foodie who taught me a thing of too about meringuehad to be replaced - so enriched is simply what it
and was I ever thankful in learning her techniques in notimplies; enriched flour has added nutrients such as iron,
have weeping meringue! But alas, we can all learnniacin, thiamine, folic acid added to the mix.
from one another, and soon she was asking meOther types of flours can also include rice, peanut,
questions about flour and which flours are perfect forpotato and of course in the world we live in, a variety
certain types of baking and cooking needs.of other different types of flours can be bought over
What is it about flour and how does it handle andthe internet from other countries and in local health
stand up to our various baking and cooking needs?stores and specialty stores.
This simple question I wished to resolve and find out -Did you know that there are pizza restaurants out in
and what I learned was more than I could almostCalifornia that have both water and flour 'imported'
handle since there seem to be several different pointsfrom NY so they can create the NY Pizza? That's is
of views as to which flour is best to use for certainhow different flours and (water) can change a recipe
baking and cooking situations.and its' basic tastes.
And as a result, a new article idea was born andI would highly recommend, trying out some of the other
hence the following is a result of today's research. Itypes of flours when you make bread the next time -
sifted through a variety of blogs and websites toexperiment with different combinations and you will
come up with the information provided below. I list thesoon be creating your own interesting hearty breads.
resources at the bottom of the article for those whoWhen in doubt, look at your package of flour to see
are so ever curious including one for the photo to thewhat combinations of additional flours and/or
above.ingredients have been added - you may find that the
Now some of you may think all flours are equal - wellwhole wheat flour is actually not completely whole
that is simply not true. Not all flours behave equallywheat but in fact has white flour already added. This is
when used in baking due to their varying levels of hardparticularly true when you wish to avoid certain 'flours'
and soft wheat flour, level of proteins including nutrients.or are trying a new bread recipe that calls for different
The flour your mother and grandmother used can betypes of flour such as rye.
very different to the flours now available on theUnbleached Versus Bleached Flour - Bleached flours
market today and certainly can behave differentlywill have a slight lower protein content than unbleached.
when used in baking and cooking. Furthermore, whatUnbleached flours will be so ever 'not as white' as
we may be able to buy in the grocery store is notbleached flours in their color. And due to the less
what your commercial baker gets and in fact allprotein amount, bleached flours when making breads
purpose flour purchased in the Northeast may be andspecifically may not rise as much and bake out flatter
will be very different than flour purchased in the South(I know this since I have experienced this).
or out West by California (who knew!?!) This wasSifted Versus Unsifted Flours - This may seem self
something I had no idea about - so how the heck doesexplanatory - but there is a huge difference in weight
one use the same cookbook (such as The Joy ofwhen comparing one cup of unsifted flour to a sifted
Cooking) in all areas of our blessed country? I am notflour. I have personally experienced a half a cup more
even going to approach that subject. But I digress.of flour once it has been sifted! Imagine adding
For many occasional bakers, all purpose flour will standunintentionally an extra half cup of flour to your recipe
up (and rise to the occassion) as needed and isand what that could do to ruin a perfectly good recipe.
perfect for almost every baking and cooking need. ForSince I mainly refer to cookbooks that are 50 years
others who are particular in their baking perfectionsold, I like to use the unsifted flour and sift accordingly to
and confections - different flours are preferred forthe recipe directions. Remember, cooking and baking is
their specific gluten contents and yeast raising abilities -chemistry - and the correct amounts make for perfect
I will try and share what I have learned about all typesresults every time.
of flours. I also included on the bottom of this article aIn most cases, my recipes will call for me to measure,
substitutions list that can come handy if you are in asift, measure again, then add the salt, baking powder,
jam for some of you bakers out there. Do note thatetc. then sift once more. Yes, I will sift my flours twice.
not all substitutions will work for every recipe - as theirBut, my cakes are extra light as are the cookies crisp
are some limitations to the chemistry compounds.and chewy as a result with having extra happy eaters.
I divided up the information into two categories, one inIf I happen to be using a pre-sifted flour (it has been
which the different flours are described, and theknown to happen) I will still carefully measure the flour,
second, which type of flour is best to be used in youradd the salt and other dry ingredients, then sift them all
different cooking and baking situations.together, since flour whether sifted or not easily settles
For the Divaliscious record, I prefer to use unbleached(like your bag of potato chips and cereals) during its
un-sifted all purpose flour such as Heckers or Kingmany travels in shipping to your local grocery store.
Arthur's for almost every baking and cooking recipeSifting the flour will aerate the flour, remove any lumps
except for when the recipe calls for cake flour (I live inand will create a lighter texture to your fine baking
the NE). I also use the same flour for my gravies andgoods. I do not sift my bread flour since I mainly use a
sauces -I am personally not a big fan of Wondrabread machine to make my dough, but will sift my flour
-though I know it helps a lot of people in avoiding lumpsfor when I make quick breads such as banana loafs,
in their gravies and sauces (but that can be avoidedetc. which I do not make in my bread machine. And for
by not adding the liquid too fast and not walking awaythe most part, I use my bread machine to simply make
from your beginning gravy stages and using a whisk tothe dough, then I take the dough out of the machine so
stir).that I can create a more homemade and rustic-looking
And of course I will sneak in some Bisquick (abread.
self-rising flour product) in making my oven-friedI use a fine mesh strainer to sift my flour - long gone
chicken, dumplings or a quick pancake or coffeecakeare my flour sifters (which you may recall seen used
when I am in a jam as it is a tried and true product -by your mother and grandmother respectively) since
but would never use Bisquick as an all purpose flour if Ithey are hard on the wrists (from all the squeezing or
was making cakes, breads or cookies from scratch.cranking mechanisms) and they rust easily while taking
Descriptions on the different type of flours:up too much room in the kitchen where space is
All Purpose Flour - is made from a blend of high andalways at a premium especially for when they are
low gluten wheats, and has a bit less protein thanused for one thing only. Why bother with sifters from
bread flour. All purpose flour sold in the North, usuallyyear's past?
has a blend of both soft and hard wheat floursThe fine mesh strainer can be used for so many
whereas in the South, it is a blend of soft wheat flours.multi-purposes in the kitchen, can be easily hand
All purpose flour can generally be used in all recipes.washed along with going into the dishwasher to be
But for the truly picky - see belows list for thecleaned that this tool is a must have in your kitchen -
preferred flour type for what you are baking andand can easily be purchased for about $6.00.
cooking.Effective, easy to clean multi-purpose gadgets are
Bread Flour - has a higher hard wheat content thanwhat I like in my kitchen - as I am sure you would want
say all purpose flour, and is used a lot by commercialthat too!
bakers. There is also a higher gluten content (moreHow To Correctly Measure Flour:
protein) in bread flour with a small amount of maltedUsing a smaller scoop, scoop up flour and place flour
barley flour and vitamin c or potassium bromate addedgently into your one cup measuring cup or other
to it in which the bromate helps increase the elasticityneeded measuring cup. With the FLAT side of a dinner
of the gluten, creating a dough with which can easilyknife, scrape gently off the excess of flour back into
be worked.your canister or bag of flour to create a leveled
Cake Flour - has a low and delicate gluten content andmeasured cup of flour. Do not pack your flour down
is finely milled with a super smooth texture allowinglike it is brown sugar for Pete's sake into your
cakes to be light and airy - think of jelly rolls, spongemeasuring cup. Doing so will result in heavy and dense
cakes and angel food cakes.baked goods. Yuck.
Pastry Flour - is finer in texture than all purpose flourPour your measured flour into your fine mesh strainer
but it is not as fine as cake flour. This flour is usuallywhich is placed above a bowl, then measure any more
distributed to commercial bakers and contains a loweradditional flour amounts that you need. By tapping the
gluten content and is made mostly of soft wheatstrainer back and forth, you will quickly sift your flour.
attributes.Just remember to measure the flour again now that it
Self-rising Flour - is an all purpose flour to whichhas been sifted once before putting your flour into
additional ingredients have been added such as bakingyour mixing bowls to get an accurate flour
powder and salt. And it should be used as accordingmeasurement.
to its package directions since there are differencesWhen my baking recipe calls for sifting (since most of
per each self-rising flour product out there - there arethem do) I will measure and then sift for the first time.
several available on the market (Bisquick comes toThen will have to measure again carefully since with
mind once again, and it was the one 'allowed' cheatingone sifting a lot of extra flour can be created - try it
self-rising flour we used in our household when I grewand see for yourself (and as mentioned previously, I
up - and still allow in my cupboard for those dumplinghave experienced over an extra 1/2 cup of flour from
moments that come to pass every once in awhilethe first sifting!) You will be amazed at the amount of
when I make a stew) - You can also make your ownextra flour which can come about from one sifting -
if you wish, just keep it in a sealed container due to theand you will now understand why your cakes are not
baking powder which you want to keep fresh to retainlike your grandmothers'! This will be a thing of the past
it's leavening properties. (1 cup self-rising flour is equalby following the simple tips as described above.
to 1 cup cake flour with 1-1/2 teaspoons bakingWhat kind of flour to use when baking and cooking:
powder and a pinch of salt added to it.)All Purpose Flour - can be used for most recipes and
Whole Grain Wheat Flour - wheat flours can vary infor general cooking and baking purposes
their amounts of white flours added, but most are triedUnbleached Unsifted flour - preferred by most fine
and true and can now be used successfully in breadbakers and cooks - great for cookies, pie crusts,
recipes without adding any additional 'white' flour.cream pies fillings, gravies
Durham/Semolina Flour - is used primarily for breadsCake flour - for your angel food cake recipes and
and pasta doughs due to its high gluten and proteincake batters and recipes requiring a light batter (not
amounts.brownies for example).
Rye Flour - rye flour usually needs to have wheat flourWheat flour - great for your bread recipes since it has
added to give it some lightness due to its lacking thea higher protein and gluten amount than say your all
necessary proteins to form gluten which is essential inpurpose flour.
making breads.Self-rising flour - preferred by Southern cooks for
Soybean Flour - Neither gliadin or glutenin, theperfect biscuits every time - one mentioned often
necessary proteins when moistened to create glutenenough is named Lily - It is not readily available here in
can be found in soybean flour, hence a strong wheatthe NE.
flour needs to be added to soy bean flour for goodSubstitutions:
results in making breads with soybean flour. Although,- 1 cup of all purpose flour = 1 cup + 2 tbsp sifted cake
with quick-breads and cakes, soybean flour may beflour
substituted up to half of the amount of all purpose flour- 1 cup sifted all-purpose flour = 1 cup minus 2 tbsp
with good results.unsifted flour
Buckwheat Flour - has very strong characteristics, a- 1 cup sifted all-purpose flour = 1 1/2 cups
nutty flavor and is very 'heavy' and must always bebreadcrumbs
combined with wheat or white flours to create goodHope this information is useful to those who need to
results in breads.know a little more about flour. Feel free to leave your
Enriched Flour - since after WWII, the demand for ancomments, ask questions and share your ideas. I look
enriched flour product was at a all time high (and theforward to hearing from you! -Divaliscious.
FDA demanded it during the war), and since due to the